THERE are no easy answers to the myriad of ethical, moral and practical issues surrounding euthanasia.
Subscribe now for unlimited access.
$0/
(min cost $0)
or signup to continue reading
If there were, we would have no need for the protracted debates that arise with every attempt to change the law.
As reporter Anita Beaumont explains today in a moving piece on the painful last days of young Hunter woman Jayde Britton, the advocacy group Dying With Dignity is gathering signatures for an online petition supporting a proposed "voluntary assisted dying" Bill from Independent Sydney MLA Alex Greenwich.
Death, no matter how it comes, is something most of us want to avoid.
Voluntary euthanasia, regardless of the method, is in essence a form of suicide, and while attitudes to suicide have varied over time and between cultures, the act of taking one's own life has historically been viewed askance.
Religious scruples might be steadily receding in Australia as we move to more secular ways of life, but death - or in this case, bringing it about more quickly than might otherwise be the case - remains one of society's great taboos.
While "traditional" morality is demonstrably at the centre of most opposition to euthanasia law reform, two other worries stand out.
One is the obvious potential for abuse, especially of the old and the frail.
The other, more amorphous, concern, relates to the boundaries of euthanasia: who should have access, and for what reasons?
And would legal protection for voluntary assisted dying lead to people opting out of situations from which they may recover?
Such issues have been debated back and forth around the world in the modern era, but only a small number of jurisdictions - including a few European countries, Canada and some US states - have legalised any form of euthanasia or assisted suicide.
'OPTING OUT' OF LIFE. A SNAPSHOT:
In Australia, legislation was passed in Victoria in 2019, while Western Australia's Voluntary Assisted Dying Act takes effect later this year.
The Northern Territory legalised euthanasia in 1996 but the federal government - with powers over territories, but not states - quashed the Act the following year. Tasmania, South Australia and NSW have all debated assisted dying Bills, but failed to pass them.
Mr Greenwich says momentum is with the movement, and Dying With Dignity has collected 15,000 of the 30,000 signatures it is seeking in an online petition.
For some, Mr Greenwich's draft legislation cannot come soon enough.
ISSUE: 39,528
IN THE NEWS:
- Demand for China from the Port of Newcastle a long game
- NSW government rebuts federal criticism of its electricity "roadmap"
- Pipes for potential Walsh Point desalination plant would run under Hunter River and Stockton
- Kurri Kurri sensation 'Mulletfest' is back in 2021
- Bull sharks caught in Lake Macquarie made waves in 2012
- Newcastle jobless rate at nine-month low as workers return to labour market
For faster access to the latest Newcastle news download our NEWCASTLE HERALD APP and sign up for breaking news, sport and what's on sent directly to your email.